Replace ISP Modem / Router

August 4, 2025 by , in Blog General

Many Internet Service Providers (ISPs) like AT&T, Comcast, Xfinity, Cox, Verizon, Spectrum, T-Mobile, and others supply a basic modem/router combo (gateway) to customers. These devices are often adequate to get online, but they may have limited Wi-Fi range, features, and firmware support.

They also come with a small number of Ethernet LAN ports, usually two to four, and those ports are often limited to 1 Gbps, which can bottleneck local network performance.

By replacing the ISP’s equipment with your own modem and router, you can save on rental fees, improve network performance, and gain advanced controls.

Why Replace Your ISP’s Router or Modem?

Various modem and router models commonly provided by internet service providers.

Using your own networking gear comes with several advantages. Firstly, it saves money. ISPs often charge monthly fees to rent their modem or router. Buying your own equipment has an upfront cost but saves money in the long run by eliminating rental fees. In some regions providers must allow approved third-party modems, allowing you to avoid these extra fees.

Secondly, as mentioned in the beginning of this article, ISP-provided routers may not offer the latest Wi-Fi 7 technology, the strongest signal, or multigig LAN ports. Upgrading to a newer router often results in improved Wi-Fi coverage and network performance.

Another reason is to gain access to advanced settings that ISP routers often hide or don’t support. Features like detailed advanced firewall, parental controls, guest networks, Quality of Service (QoS) bandwidth management, and client/server VPN support are commonly available on retail and open-source routers.

Also, for better device security. Third-party or open-source routers frequently receive firmware updates directly from the manufacturer or community. In contrast, ISP routers are usually not be updated promptly or sometimes not updated at all.

Linux and open-source enthusiasts can install open-source firmware like OpenWrt, DD-WRT, OPNsense, or pfSense on compatible hardware for even more functionality. This might include ad-blocking or dynamic routing protocols. You can do this even using your own hardware appliance as your router.

If you prefer proprietary solutions, you can replace gear with solutions like a Unifi Cloud Gateway, Firewalla, Sophos XG Home, or others.

Of course, when you replace the ISP’s hardware, you become responsible for managing your network. You’ll need to configure and troubleshoot your equipment (the ISP’s support becomes limited to only when their line is down). For most users this is manageable, but it’s a trade-off to be aware of.

Now, let’s look at how to approach replacing the ISP hardware for different connection types.

Cable vs. DSL vs. Fiber Internet Connections

Cable, DSL, and fiber internet cables, showing physical differences between each connection type.

Before you buy any new hardware for your home network, identify what type of internet service you have. The process for replacing equipment differs if you have cable, fiber, or DSL. The physical medium—coaxial cable, fiber-optic, or telephone line (DSL)—determines whether you need a modem and a router, or just a router.

Below we explain each ISP connection type and how you can use your own router or modem in each case. We won’t go into detail on less popular wireless mobile (LTE or 5G) and satellite ISP connections. But the same principles apply. In my case, I used a Peplink Balance 20x to replace my ISP’s LTE modem for internet connectivity. For satellite, Starlink is very popular.

Cable Internet (DOCSIS Cable Modem)

Close-up of a coaxial cable used for cable internet connections.

Cable internet uses a coaxial cable line (coax) and a DOCSIS cable modem to translate signals. Many ISP-supplied cable modems also include built-in Wi-Fi router functionality (forming a gateway). Users can choose to replace the entire gateway or put the ISP device in bridge mode and use a separate router.

If your internet comes through coax, you have cable broadband. The device your ISP gave you is either a cable modem (if it has one Ethernet WAN port) or a cable gateway (modem plus router/Wi-Fi in one box).

The modem handles communication with the cable company (ISP) over a coax cable, while the router (if integrated) distributes that connection to your devices via Ethernet and/or Wi-Fi. You can use your own router by disabling the ISP modem’s Wi-Fi and ignoring its LAN ports, but the better solution is to replace the modem as well. This eliminates the ISP box entirely, giving you full control and ending rental fees.

Check with your cable ISP for approved modem models. Most providers and modem manufacturers maintain a list of compatible modems. Ensure the modem supports at least DOCSIS 3.0 or 3.1, depending on your plan’s speed. For gigabit cable plans, a DOCSIS 3.1 modem is required. Buying a modem that’s on an approved list and supports your speed tier is essential; otherwise, your ISP might refuse to activate it!

How to replace your cable modem

Replacing a cable modem is straightforward. First, note the new modem’s MAC address (a unique ID printed on the device). Disconnect the old device and hook up the coax cable and power to your new modem. Once it’s powered and connected, you typically need to activate it with the ISP so they register its MAC address on their network.

Many ISPs offer a self-activation webpage or phone line for this purpose. For example, Comcast Xfinity and Spectrum have web portals where you log in and follow steps to add a new modem. Alternatively, you may call customer support and provide the modem’s MAC and your account details for activation. After a short synchronization, the modem should come online.

Once the modem is online, connect your personal router’s WAN (Internet) port to the modem’s WAN port. Your router should receive a public IP address from the ISP (via DHCP) if everything is configured correctly (with the ISP’s gateway removed or in bridge mode). If the modem you bought is a standalone (no built-in Wi-Fi), using your own router is required for home networking.

If you were renting the ISP’s modem, don’t forget to return it once your own is working. Most ISPs will stop charging a monthly fee when their equipment is returned.

Keep the cable modem but add your own router

If you cannot buy a new modem (or choose not to), you can still use your own router by putting the ISP’s gateway into bridge mode. Bridge mode turns off the ISP’s device routing/NAT functions and passes the public IP through to your router.

Every ISP gateway’s interface is different, but look for a “Bridge Mode” or “Passthrough” setting in its admin pages. If bridge mode is unavailable, a workaround is to use the ISP device’s DMZ feature to expose your router, or at worst, accept a double NAT. (Double NAT means your router is behind the ISP router; it usually still lets you browse the web fine, but complicates certain advanced applications. It’s a last resort if the ISP locks down their gear.)

DSL Internet (Phone Line DSL)

Note: If you have DSL, you are probably better off upgrading to a fiber or even cable ISP, rather than spending money on DSL hardware, as it is the oldest and most limiting of the three technologies.

DSL (Digital Subscriber Line) runs over telephone lines. It uses a DSL modem to connect. While less common now (many regions have upgraded to cable or fiber), some homes still use ADSL/VDSL especially in rural areas. Replacing a DSL modem/router has some extra considerations.

Unlike cable modems which follow DOCSIS standards, DSL technologies vary (ADSL2+, VDSL2, etc.) and are sometimes tied to the ISP’s network gear. You may be able to purchase your own DSL modem, but ensure it supports the same standard and Annex (A vs B, etc.) that your ISP uses. Some ISPs allow approved third-party DSL modems; others might only support their provided unit. Check your ISP’s help pages or user forums for models that have worked for others.

Often, the ISP’s DSL modem is also a router/Wi-Fi combo. Like with cable modems, you can use bridge mode. Then you can connect your own router for all routing tasks.  If bridge mode isn’t available, using your router in DMZ or double NAT on DSL is possible but not ideal because it can create issues with gaming, streaming, VPN, etc.

Many DSL ISPs use PPPoE (Point-to-Point Protocol over Ethernet) for authentication. If so, you’ll need your ISP-issued username and password. When you use your own equipment, you must enter these credentials into your router’s WAN settings (if bridging the ISP modem) or into the new DSL modem. This allows it to log into the ISP network. You can sometimes find these credentials by downloading the raw xml or json backup files.

Lastly, simply swapping DSL modems may not work until the new modem is configured correctly (VPI/VCI numbers, modulation settings, etc., if applicable). Some providers lock the line to the modem’s MAC or serial. Overall, it’s possible to use your own router with DSL as well. The benefit, again, is better Wi-Fi, LAN speeds, and features than the typically outdated ISP unit. Weigh the pros and cons.

Fiber Internet (FTTH with ONT)

Fiber-to-the-home (FTTH) is increasingly common. If your ISP ran an optical fiber to your residence, they likely provided an ONT (Optical Network Terminal). An ONT is essentially the “modem” for fiber. It converts the fiber optic light signals into a standard Ethernet network connection.

The ONT’s Ethernet hand-off (WAN) works with any standard router, so you don’t need a special “fiber router”, just one with a gigabit (or faster) WAN port. Set that WAN port for DHCP or, if required, PPPoE/VLAN tagging. Check your ISP’s documentation for the exact settings.

Replacing an ISP Fiber Gateway

Some ISPs ship a combined ONT + router. You have two practical options:

  1. Bridge or “ONT passthrough” mode (disables routing, leaving only ONT functions, so you can run your own router behind it).
  2. Swap for a standalone ONT (request a pure ONT if you don’t need the ISP’s Wi-Fi features).

If neither option is offered, you can still attach your router and use DMZ or accept double-NAT, but bridging is cleaner.

Deleting the ONT altogether

Note: If your ISP bundles VoIP or IPTV, those may still rely on the original gateway or a dedicated ONT port. Confirm with the provider how to keep those services working when you supply your own router or optics.

While most customers must keep the ISP-supplied ONT, a handful of providers allow you to terminate the fiber directly in your router’s SFP/SFP+ cage using a compatible GPON or XGS-PON optical module. In these scenarios the router handles PPPoE (or DHCP/VLAN) itself and the ONT can be removed entirely.

This approach is niche; your router must support the exact PON standard, and you’ll need the ISP’s serial/LOID or authentication details. For deep-dive guides and stick/SFP module compatibility lists, see the community-maintained wiki at hack-gpon.org.


I purchased this GPON stick to delete my ISP’s ONT from my home lab network.

Throughout this process, remember that you can always reconnect the old router or gateway if you need to troubleshoot or if you hit an outage. It’s wise to keep the ISP device until you’re confident your new setup is stable. Once you’ve run successfully for a few weeks, you likely won’t need the old unit at all.

Great. I’ll compile an organized HTML index of all internal links from your article, plus external resources—manufacturers, community wikis, forums, modem/router databases, and fiber/DSL/Cable-related websites—especially those relevant to Linux and open-source users or those who enjoy customizing network setups. I’ll sort them into logical categories for easy reference and paste-ready use in WordPress.

Useful Resources and Links

Below is a curated index of reputable resources, compatibility lists, and support pages to help you choose, configure, and troubleshoot third-party modem and router hardware across cable, DSL, and fiber connections.

Open-Source Router Firmware & Compatibility

Cable-Modem & DOCSIS Resources

DSL Reference & BYO Guides

Fiber/GPON & ONT Replacement

Open-Source Firewall/Router Platforms

  • pfSense Project – FreeBSD-based firewall with VPN, IDS/IPS, and traffic shaping.
  • OPNsense Platform – Fork of pfSense featuring frequent updates and modern UI.
  • IPFire Firewall – Lightweight Linux distribution focused on security, IPS, geo-blocking.
  • Zenarmor for OPNsense – Adds application control, TLS inspection, analytics to OPNsense.

Mesh Wi-Fi Reviews & Buying Guides

Manufacturer Support & Product Portals

Additional Articles & Resources

Router Tips and Best Practices

The above covers the basics for both beginners and intermediate. For those with a bit more networking knowledge or curiosity, here are additional considerations:

Open-Source Router OS

If you have a spare PC or single-board computer, you can build a custom router using open-source operating systems like pfSense, OPNsense, or IPFire_. This can deliver enterprise-level control and insight into your home network. It’s more hands-on but highly educational. For example, some users repurpose an old PC or a Raspberry Pi 5 with dual network interfaces as a router, installing OpenWrt or Debian to fine-tune everything. Just ensure the hardware can handle your internet speed (gigabit routing can be CPU-intensive without specialized hardware).

Aftermarket Firmware on Commercial Routers

Many off-the-shelf routers support replacing the factory firmware with open-source alternatives (like OpenWrt, DD-WRT, FreshTomato, etc.). This can breathe new life into a device by adding features the manufacturer didn’t include. Check the router’s model compatibility on the firmware’s website before attempting this. Open-source firmware can allow things like running a VPN client for all traffic, advanced monitoring, or integrating with home automation.

Mesh Networking and Coverage

If your goal in replacing the ISP router is better wireless coverage, consider a mesh Wi-Fi system or a router + extenders. Mesh systems (e.g., Google Nest WiFi, Eero, Netgear Orbi, etc.) can blanket a home in reliable Wi-Fi, and they can usually be used with any modem/ONT. You would still replace or bridge the ISP gateway, then connect the mesh base unit as your main router. This is beginner-friendly while still improving performance.

Conclusion

Replacing your ISP’s modem/router can seem intimidating to newcomers, but it’s a one-time effort that often pays off in a better internet experience. We’ve seen that cable users can enjoy full control with their own modem and a high-performance router, fiber users can plug into that blazing fast ONT with a router of their choice, and even DSL folks can often tweak or swap equipment for improvements. The key is understanding your connection type and following a few setup steps diligently.

By taking charge of your home network hardware, you gain the freedom to use open-source solutions, configure your network to your heart’s content, and ensure you’re not overpaying for subpar equipment. Many tech enthusiasts consider this a right of passage – a move from being a passive consumer of whatever router the ISP hands you, to being the master of your own home network. And even if you’re not a tech guru, simply enjoying stronger Wi-Fi, better coverage, and the peace of mind of no rental fees makes it worthwhile.

In summary, don’t be afraid to make the switch. With the tips in this guide and a bit of research into your specific ISP’s requirements, anyone can upgrade their network setup. Your favorite Linux and open-source-powered devices on your network will thank you for it! Happy networking!

Tags: , , ,



Top ↑